I Stained My Cedar Front Porch (And I Hate It!)

Hate is a robust phrase. Perhaps I’m simply drained and annoyed, and it’s not as dangerous as I feel it’s. However after spending yesterday staining my entrance porch that I had spent hours strain washing, sanding, and prepping for a brand new stain and sealer, I’m not in any respect happy with the way it turned out. I ended up utilizing Prepared Seal in Darkish Walnut, and it simply didn’t end up like I had hoped.

I had deliberate on utilizing Cabot Australian Timber Oil, and primarily based on the true wooden coloration samples that I noticed on the retailer, I chosen the colour Jarrah Brown.

I want I had taken an image of the Jarrah Brown wooden pattern at Lowe’s. It was so fairly. It was a medium-to-light brown with no instantly noticeable undertones. It didn’t look greenish brown, and it didn’t seem like a reddish brown. It was only a very impartial medium/mild brown, and it was precisely what I wished.

However after I opened it up, stirred it, and examined it on an not noticeable board on my entrance porch, it was RED. I don’t even imply that it had refined pink undertones. I imply it was RED. I went to the Lowe’s web site to see what the heck was occurring, and as I scrolled by means of the client photographs on the Jarrah Brown itemizing, the colours appeared to be in all places, from medium brown to very pink. Clearly, the variations are as a result of it’s being utilized to several types of wooden, however the outcomes have been so diverse! And I didn’t see any that regarded like that stunning medium/mild impartial brown pattern within the retailer.

I forgot to take an image of the pattern on my entrance porch, however this one is fairly near what it regarded like.

I’m very glad that buyer is pleased with that consequence, however to say that that’s the very reverse of what I wished could be an enormous understatement. That deck seems to be prefer it’s glowing to me.

I didn’t really feel like going again and taking a look at different colours. I had already spent approach an excessive amount of time within the deck stain aisles of Lowe’s and Residence Depot studying labels, evaluating pattern colours, wanting up buyer critiques, and so forth. And now I used to be sure that these samples can’t be trusted anyway. I’d have simply as a lot luck selecting a coloration by closing my eyes, spinning round a number of occasions, after which randomly pointing at a can of stain.

So I made a decision to return to my earlier choice, which I had already bought and had on the home. This one was Prepared Seal in Darkish Walnut. I had hoped to do one thing a little bit lighter this time, however I actually did like my Darkish Walnut entrance porch the primary time round, so I made a decision to keep it up. However the first time, I used a unique model. This time, I made a decision to go along with Prepared Seal as a result of it does have excellent buyer scores. And this was approach higher than the Cabot Jarrah Brown.

Properly, I don’t like it. The primary time I stained my porch again in 2018, I used Thompson’s Timber Oil in Darkish Walnut. It turned out like this…

It was actually darkish, but it surely was lovely and impartial, and it regarded so fairly with the white trim and coral door. Right here’s how the Prepared Seal Darkish Walnut turned out…

It’s orange. I now have an orange entrance porch. I sidestepped the terrible pink with the Cabot, however then went proper to orange with Prepared Seal. I ought to have caught with Thompson’s.

I’m so annoyed proper now. I do know I’m the queen of “if I don’t prefer it, I’ll simply redo it!” However y’all, my studio cupboards are being delivered tomorrow, and redoing a entrance porch is actually the very last thing on this planet I need to be targeted on proper now.

However that is terrible. That Thompson’s darkish walnut regarded so fairly with my coral entrance door. This orange clashes, and I simply don’t assume I can reside with this coloration. I’ll be disillusioned each single time I stroll out my entrance door, and for this to be the primary impression of our home will not be what I need.

The excellent news is that from a distance, it’s not so dangerous. It’s not nice, but it surely’s not dangerous. (Please excuse the sanding mud that I forgot to hoover off the siding earlier than staining the porch.)

However even from a distance, it’s nonetheless orange. And it nonetheless clashes with the entrance door. It’s simply not so noticeable from a distance. However as you method the entrance door, the porch will get increasingly orange the nearer you get to it.

So now I’ve to determine learn how to repair this. I known as the corporate, and the girl I spoke with mentioned they’ve a coloration known as Mission Brown that’s darkish with out the orange/pink undertones (a coloration that I didn’t see on any of their pattern playing cards…ugh!), and I might use that to do one other coat over the Darkish Walnut to chop the orange. The issue with that concept is that except Mission Brown truly has inexperienced undertones to it, I don’t assume it’s going to be sufficient to chop the orange/pink coloration of this Darkish Walnut. I want some precise inexperienced or bluish inexperienced to chop counteract this orange/pink coloration. Only a impartial brown (which is how she described it) will not be sufficient. However that’s what she beneficial, in order that’s one possibility.

She additionally mentioned that some contractors will add pigments to the stain to get a customized coloration. She didn’t suggest that possibility as a result of it could have an effect on the efficiency of the sealer, and it might be one thing I’d must attempt at my very own danger (which means, if the efficiency of the sealer fails, they’re not at fault, clearly), but it surely’s nonetheless one thing I’ll think about. It simply must be a pigment that’s suitable with oil-based merchandise. Heck, I’ve small tubes of inexperienced and blue oil-based paint. I’ll even attempt including these to the leftover stain to see if that eliminates the orange/pink coloration.

So I don’t have it discovered but. However what I do know is that I’ve to give you an answer, as a result of having an orange wooden entrance porch that clashes with my coral door will not be an possibility.

So far as the product itself goes (other than the colour), Prepared Seal appears fairly nice. It was very straightforward to use. I simply used a big 4-inch brush for oil-based merchandise, and it went on very simply and easily. I stirred it very completely earlier than utilizing it, after which stirred it a number of occasions throughout software simply to maintain the pigments from settling to the underside. However so far as software goes, it truly is goof proof, simply because the label says. Now I simply have to get the colour proper.

Addicted 2 Adorning is the place I share my DIY and adorning journey as I rework and enhance the 1948 fixer higher that my husband, Matt, and I purchased in 2013. Matt has M.S. and is unable to do bodily work, so I do the vast majority of the work on the home on my own. You’ll be able to study extra about me right here.

I hope you’ll be part of me on my DIY and adorning journey! If you wish to comply with my initiatives and progress, you may subscribe under and have every new put up delivered to your electronic mail inbox. That approach you’ll by no means miss a factor!